Bridgland, D.R. 1994. Quaternary of the Thames. Geological Conservation Review Series No. 7. JNCC, Peterborough, ISBN 0 412 48830 2. The original source material for these web pages has been made available by the JNCC under the Open Government Licence 3.0. Full details in the JNCC Open Data Policy
Little Oakley
D.R. Bridgland
Highlights
Extremely rare Cromerian deposits, with important molluscan and mammalian faunas, occur here in a channel cut through pre-diversion Thames-Medway gravels. This association is important for the correlation of the Thames terrace sequence with the type Cromerian of Norfolk and the more complete 'Cromerian Complex' succession of The Netherlands.
Introduction
At Little Oakley, in the north-eastern corner of the Tendring Plateau
The interglacial deposits at Little Oakley were first discovered in 1939 by Warren (1940; Sutcliffe et al., 1979), who recognized that they were of 'Forest Beds' (Cromerian) age. The site has been frequently cited in subsequent literature as an important Cromerian locality, a considerable rarity outside the type area of north Norfolk (Oakley, 1943; Kerney, 1959a; Turner, 1973; Sutcliffe et al., 1979). However, prior to the recent investigations (Bridgland et al., 1988, 1990), which included re-excavation of the deposits as part of the GCR programme (Bridgland, 1985a), no detailed study of the sediments or in situ sampling had been attempted.
Description
Little Oakley lies near the eastern end of a ridge of London Clay, capped with Pleistocene gravels and small remnants of Red Crag, lying between the Stour estuary to the north, Hamford Water to the south and the North Sea to the east. On the only available Geological Survey map (Old Series, Sheet 48), the deposits capping this ridge are classified as 'Glacial Gravel' (Whitaker, 1877). However, gravels of this type throughout Suffolk and Essex have been shown to pre-date the Anglian Stage, during which the principal glacial deposits in this region were laid down, from the fact that their upper layers show evidence of warm-climate soil formation (the Valley Farm Soil) prior to burial by Anglian till. Such gravels are now interpreted as deposits of the pre-diversion Thames and classified as the Kesgrave Sands and Gravels Group (Rose et al., 1976; see above, Introduction to Part 1).
The Kesgrave Sands and Gravels have been progressively subdivided during the past decade (Hey, 1980; Allen, 1983, 1984; Bridgland, 1988a; Whiteman, 1990) and are now considered to represent various formations within High-level and Low-level Kesgrave Subgroups. The gravel in the vicinity of Little Oakley is attributed to the Oakley Formation, which represents the downstream continuation of the Ardleigh Formation (
The Little Oakley channel deposits were not recognized in the Old Series Geological Survey mapping, although a patch of Red Crag is indicated on the map at their approximate location, suggesting that the fluviatile shelly sand may have been mistaken for part of the Crag. In recent investigations, however, a remnant of Red Crag was encountered between the interglacial channel sediments and the London Clay (Bridgland et al., 1990).
No permanent section has ever existed at Little Oakley, the sediments originally being discovered in spoil from sewer trenches (Warren, 1940). Detailed work at the locality has been carried out in recent years (Bridgland et al., 1988, 1990). Using Warren's notes, the fossiliferous channel was relocated by augering near to the site of the original discovery (borehole LOA,
Detailed mapping of the interglacial deposits at Little Oakley has demonstrated that they fill a WSW–ENE trending channel between 150 m and 175 m wide
The fluviatile Oakley Gravel and Little Oakley Silts and Sands are capped by a complex, poorly bedded unit of variable thickness. This unit, which predominantly comprises silty or clayey sand with pebbles and calcareous nodules, thickening downslope, has been attributed to solifluction (Bridgland et al., 1990). The sequence at Little Oakley can thus be summarized as follows (for thicknesses, see
3. Colluvium
2. Little Oakley Silts and Sands
1. Oakley Gravel
Pre-Pleistocene strata: London Clay and Waltonian Red Crag
Interpretation
The Little Oakley site, after several decades of neglect, has benefited recently from a multidisciplinary appraisal using modern techniques. The sedimentological interpretation has been restricted, however, by the lack of exposure; the reconstruction of the three-dimensional form of the sediment body has relied primarily on augering and occasional temporary excavations. The best evidence for palaeoenvironmental conditions has therefore come from studies of the palaeontology.
The Little Oakley Silts and Sands contain rich assemblages of freshwater molluscs and ostracods, comprising taxa indicative of deposition in the lower reaches of a large, well-oxygenated, calcareous river, upstream from any tidal influence (Preece, 1990b; Robinson, 1990). Terrestrial mollusca are also present, which testifies that the river had wide, open floodplains with fringing marsh habitats (indicated, for example, by Vertigo antivertigo (Draparnaud) and Zonitoides nitidus (Müller)) and extensive areas of dry, calcareous grassland (indicated by Trochoidea geyeri (Soos) and Truncatellina cylindrica (Férussac)) (Preece, 1990b). Pollen analyses have confirmed the presence of grassland, but have suggested that woodland also existed in the catchment during most of the time represented (Gibbard and Peglar, 1990). The vertebrate assemblage includes species typical of fluviatile, marsh, grassland and woodland environments (Lister et al., 1990), supporting the evidence from the pollen and molluscs.
A more detailed assessment of the palynology (Gibbard and Peglar, 1990) reveals that early herb-dominated vegetation gave way to boreal forest, with birch and pine dominant, and then to deciduous forest in which oak and particularly elm were major constituents. This vegetational history was reconstructed from the palynological records of several separate boreholes, since deposits in different parts of the channel were found to represent different time periods (Gibbard and Peglar, 1990). The earliest fossiliferous sediments, shown by pollen analyses to date from the transition from cold conditions at the beginning of an interglacial, have been found only on the southern margin of the channel; the basal channel sediments become progressively younger northwards (Gibbard and Peglar, 1990). The Mollusca from borehole LOO, near the southern edge of the channel, record a progressive replacement of aquatic taxa by marsh snails (as above), thus indicating a shallowing sequence (Preece, 1990b). This suggests that this part of the feature was filled as the active channel shifted northwards. The precise width of the active channel must therefore have been somewhat less than the maximum width of the Little Oakley Silts and Sands sediment body.
The vertebrate assemblages from the channel deposits are fully temperate in character. Knowledge of the modern breeding requirements of certain fish species (Cyprinidae and Percidae) recovered from Little Oakley suggests that during the summer months (May–August) water temperatures must have reached a minimum of 15°C and a maximum of 22°C, whereas in winter (December–March) they must have fallen no lower than 0.6°C. Moreover, the occurrence of the pond tortoise (Emys orbicularis) implies mean July temperatures well in excess of 18°C if, as seems likely, this represents a breeding population (Lister et al., 1990).
Palaeogeography
Little Oakley lies in an area that is highly important for the study of Pleistocene geology, since it is one in which the Thames and East Anglian stratigraphies can be compared. The results of clast-lithological analysis indicate that the Oakley Gravel, the terrace formation into which the Little Oakley Silts and Sands are channelled, is part of the pre-diversion Thames drainage system (Bridgland, 1988a; see above). Detailed clast compositional data from the Tendring Plateau
The ratio of southern material to quartz and quartzites has been employed to demonstrate the change in clast composition resulting from the confluence between the Kesgrave Thames and the Medway (Bridgland, 1988a; Bridgland et al., 1990). In the gravels upstream from the confluence, this ratio is relatively low, ranging from 0.02 to 0.10. A ratio of approximately 0.10 is considered to represent the upstream limit of Medway influence, this being the highest ratio encountered in Kesgrave Group gravels further upstream. Ratios generally increase downstream from this westward limit to 0.50 and above (Bridgland, 1988a; Bridgland et al., 1990;
The composition of the Oakley Gravel in the vicinity of Little Oakley shows it to fall within the Thames-Medway category; in particular, southern to quartz and quartzite ratios in excess of 0.10 were revealed
Biostratigraphy and correlation
The palaeontological evidence from the Little Oakley Silts and Sands not only enables detailed palaeoecological reconstructions, but also provides evidence for the relative age of the deposits. The pollen assemblages, from various profiles through the deposits, together represent the early part (biozones I and II) of an early Middle Pleistocene interglacial (Bridgland, 1990b; Gibbard and Peglar, 1990). Hornbeam (Carpinus) and 'Tertiary relics' (such as Tsuga, Carya or Eucommia) are absent, suggesting that the deposits are unlikely to be of pre-Cromerian age. A number of features of the pollen record are suggestive of a Cromerian (sensu West Runton) age: Ulmus (elm) expands early and becomes dominant, Picea (spruce) is present throughout, whereas Quercus (oak) expands late and is followed by Corylus (hazel). The similarity between this sequence of woodland development and that of the Cromerian stratotype at West Runton, Norfolk, has led to suggestions that the two sites may be correlatives (Bridgland et al., 1988, 1990).
The vertebrate fauna is also suggestive of a broadly Cromerian age for the Little Oakley Silts and Sands (Lister et al., 1990). The presence of the giant deer Megaloceros verticornis and M. dawkinsi, together with the vole Mimomys savini, strongly indicate deposition during the early Middle Pleistocene. In western Europe these two deer species are restricted to deposits of Cromerian and early Elsterian (Anglian) ages, whereas M savini extends from the late Early Pleistocene to the type Cromerian, but is replaced in some late pre-Anglian ('late Cromerian') assemblages by its evolutionary descendant, Arvicola cantiana (see Chapter 1). The Little Oakley vertebrate fauna is fully temperate in character; it clearly represents an interglacial later than the Pastonian Stage but earlier than those 'late Cromerian' sites with A. cantiana, such as Westbury-sub-Mendip (Bishop, 1982).
The rich vertebrate fauna from the West Runton Freshwater Bed (biozones CrIb–IIb) shares with Little Oakley such characteristic extinct taxa as the water vole Mimomys savini, the pine vole Pitymys gregaloides (Hinton), the Etruscan rhinoceros Dicerorhinus etruscus and the giant deer Megaloceros verticornis (Stuart, 1975, 1981, 1982a). The much more limited fauna from Little Oakley compares closely with that of West Runton, although pond tortoise (Emys orbicularis) has not yet been recorded from the latter. Shrew remains from Little Oakley represent a potentially valuable means of comparison with the fauna from West Runton, in which Sorex species of three different sizes occur. There are indications from the collections accumulated to date from Little Oakley that a similar assemblage of shrews occurs, but further sampling is required in order to obtain crucial mandibular remains (Lister et al, 1990).
The molluscan assemblage from Little Oakley includes Tanousia, a genus known only from the Cromerian in Britain. Valvata naticina, Bithynia troscheli and Unio crassus are unknown in Britain before this stage. The presence of B. troscheli to the exclusion of Bithynia tentaculata is a feature that characterizes most British Cromerian sites. These features of the assemblage are consistent with a broadly Cromerian age, although the same taxa are found in 'earlier sediments in The Netherlands and elsewhere (Preece, 1990b). Recent consideration of the molluscan assemblages from Cromerian (sensu lato) sites in Britain and north-west Europe (Meijer and Preece, in press) suggests that the Little Oakley fauna is peculiar, thus far, to this one locality. Meijer and Preece point to significant differences between molluscan faunas that can be regarded as 'early' and others that can be regarded as 'late' within the 'Cromerian Complex'. Significant taxa amongst the 'early' assemblages are Valvata goldfussiana and Tanousia runtoniana, extinct species that do not seem to survive into the 'late' faunas. The 'late' assemblages have V. naticina, Belgrandia marginata and Bithynia tentaculata, which have yet to be found in the 'early' faunas, and are indistinguishable, malacologically, from Hoxnian (Holsteinian) assemblages. The British sites at West Runton and Sugworth both have molluscan faunas that can be classified, according to these criteria, as 'early'. Other British Cromerian (sensu lato) sites such as Sidestrand and Trimmingham have yielded the 'late' type of molluscan assemblage. Little Oakley, uniquely, has a fauna that seems intermediate between these two categories. Valvata goldfussiana, an element of the 'early' fauna, is absent, whereas Bithynia tentaculata is present. The Tanousia from Little Oakley is a different species from that found at West Runton and is close to, but smaller than, T. stenostoma a species recognized in Denmark (Preece, 1990b). Meijer and Preece (in press) have suggested that the Little Oakley site represents a later temperate episode within the 'Cromerian Complex' than either West Runton or Sugworth.
Significant amongst the ostracod fauna from Little Oakley are Candona tricicatricosa (Diebel and Pietrzeniuk), Ilyocypris quinculminata (Sylvester and Bradley), Sclerocypris clavata prisca (Diebel and Pietrzeniuk) and Scottia browniana. None of these is restricted to the Cromerian, but they are unknown together in Britain after the Hoxnian, thus supporting a broadly Middle Pleistocene age (Robinson, 1990).
Bridgland et al. (1990) have cited amino acid ratios from shells from Little Oakley, analysed by two different laboratories. Specimens of both Valvata piscinalis and V. naticina were analysed in London (London Quaternary Centre; laboratory now relocated to the Institute of Earth Sciences, the University College of Wales, Aberystwyth), and ratios from V. naticina were also obtained in Colorado (INSTAAR Laboratory). The D : L ratios from V. piscinalis are somewhat higher than those from V. naticina, which may indicate that epimerization is faster in the former species. Comparison with V. piscinalis ratios from other Middle Pleistocene sites is informative, the following being listed by Bridgland et al. (1990) and/or Bowen et al. (1989):
Site | Mean D : L ratios | Laboratory |
Hoxne | 0.243 ± 0.023 (n=3) | INSTAAR |
Hoxne | 0.261 ± 0.01 (n=4) | London |
Swanscombe | 0.30 ± 0.016 (n=10) | London |
Swanscombe | 0.297 ± 0.009 (n=5) | INSTAAR |
Clacton | 0.299 ± 0.002 (n=3) | London |
Little Oakley | 0.324 ± 0.004 (n=2) | London |
Little Oakley | 0.336 ± 0.027 (n=4) | London |
West Runton | 0.348 ± 0.011 (n=5) | London |
These ratios are consistent with a broad correlation between Little Oakley and West Runton and confirm that these sites are older than those at Hoxne, Swanscombe and Clacton, all attributed to the Hoxnian Stage (sensu lato). However, ratios from V. goldfussiana shells from Sugworth compare closely with those quoted above from Swanscombe and Clacton, despite the convincing biostratigraphical indications that this site is a broad correlative of Little Oakley and West Runton (see Chapter 2, Sugworth).
The stratigraphical record of the lower Middle Pleistocene in Britain, best represented on the Norfolk coast, is now known to be far from complete (Zalasiewicz and Gibbard, 1988). Comparison with the sequence in The Netherlands, in particular, shows that repeated climatic fluctuations occurred in the period following the Matuyama–Brunhes palaeomagnetic reversal and prior to the Elsterian (= Anglian) Stage; four warm/cold climatic cycles are recognized below Elsterian tills in The Netherlands and are collectively termed the 'Cromerian Complex', the magnetic reversal occurring between the peak of the earliest of the four temperate episodes and the trough of the succeeding glacial (Zagwijn et al., 1971; de Jong, 1988; Chapter 1).
Exactly how the Little Oakley interglacial relates to the 'Cromerian Complex' of The Netherlands is difficult to determine, as the four interglacials comprising this complex were distinguished using palynology alone. Correlation with 'Cromerian Complex Interglacial I' (or earlier temperate intervals) is precluded by the absence of Tertiary relics such as Eucommia and Tsuga (Gibbard and Peglar, 1990). Similarly, the absence of Taxus and/or Carpinus in the early temperate substage (biozone II) differentiates the sequence in the Little Oakley Silts and Sands from 'Cromerian Complex Intergjacials II and III'. There are similarities, however, between the palynology of little Oakley and Noordbergum, a site in The Netherlands that has been assigned to 'Interglacial IV' (de Jong, 1988). Noordbergum has also been tentatively correlated with the Cromerian stratotype at West Runton (Zagwijn, 1985), a suggestion supported by amino acid ratios from Noordbergum (Miller and Mangerud, 1985). However, the recent recognition of Arvicola cantiana amongst collections from Noordbergum (von Kolfschoten, 1988) argues against these correlations, since the earlier vole Mimomys savini occurs at both West Runton and Little Oakley, rather than A. cantiana (Stuart, 1975, 1981, 1982a; Bridgland et al., 1988). This has led to the suggestion that the Dutch sequence is itself incomplete, that the British Cromerian (sensu stricto) is missing in The Netherlands and that Little Oakley and West Runton are broadly of 'late Cromerian Complex' age (Bridgland et al., 1990).
The Matuyama–Brunhes palaeomagnetic boundary is recognized as a highly significant stratigraphical marker within the Pleistocene, widely adopted as the base of the Middle Pleistocene (Richmond and Fullerton, 1986). Since this magnetic reversal approximately coincides, in the sedimentary record, with the end of 'Cromerian Complex Interglacial I' of the Dutch sequence, palaeomagnetic information is of considerable value in the study of sites of 'Cromerian Complex' age. The polarity of the Little Oakley Silts and Sands has been established as normal (Austin, in Bridgland et al., 1990), indicating deposition after the Matuyama–Brunhes reversal and therefore after 'Cromerian Complex Interglacial I' of The Netherlands. This implies an age of somewhat less than 780,000 years BP, the approximate date of the magnetic reversal (Shackleton et al., 1990).
Within the British sequence, the interglacial at Little Oakley has been interpreted as more recent than that at Ardleigh, since the Little Oakley Channel is cut through the local Oakley Gravel, the downstream equivalent of the Ardleigh Gravel (Gibbard, 1988b; Bridgland et al., 1990). It is important to note, however, that the Little Oakley Silts and Sands occupy a position well below the original upper surface level of the Oakley Formation, in an area of considerable dissection
Conclusions
The Little Oakley interglacial site is clearly a critical locality for Pleistocene palaeontology and stratigraphy. The interglacial sediments, filling a channel cut through the local early Thames-Medway gravel (the Oakley Gravel), are richly fossiliferous, yielding pollen and the remains of molluscs, ostracods, mammals and fish. The combination of the various fossil types present indicates that the sediments represent a period of generally warm climate, comparable to that of the present day. The pollen provides a detailed record of climatic and vegetational change during the first half of an interglacial (temperate) period. The mammals include the extinct vole Mimomys savini, the Etruscan rhinoceros and the giant deer Megaloceros verticornis. These species, as well as certain extinct molluscs from Little Oakley, are characteristic of several temperate-climate episodes that, alternating with colder periods, preceded the major glaciation during which the Thames was diverted. This period of fluctuating climate, recognized in The Netherlands and called the 'Cromerian Complex', covers a long span of Pleistocene time, between around 750,000 and 450,000 years BP. The name derives from the Cromerian Stage, defined in north Norfolk, which is thought to coincide with part of the 'Cromerian Complex'. The significance of the Little Oakley interglacial deposits is heightened by the fact that they occur within the early terrace deposits of the Thames system. They therefore provide a means for dating the Thames terrace sequence and to enable improved correlation between the Thames Basin and Pleistocene sequences in other parts of Britain and western Europe.