Bailey, et al. 1924. Tertiary and Post-Tertiary geology of Mull, Loch Aline, and Oban (a description of parts of sheets 43, 44, 51, and 52 of the geological map). HMSO [for Geological Survey]
Chapter 16 Agglomerates or breccias of vents
Introduction
It has been pointed out in Chapter 15 that tumultuous agglomerate or breccia, plays a very important part in the geology of Central Mull; and that, while considerable masses of it seem to be remnants of surface-accumulations, others again certainly occupy eruptive vents. These latter are lettered V on the one-inch Map. Here and there, the difference of field-relations in the two cases has been obscured by later happenings, but
When the transgressive relationships of much of the breccia were first realized, two interpretations seemed possible: either the transgressive breccias might be a scree-formation blocking valleys of erosion, or they might be—as all now agree they are—a volcanic agglomerate choking funnels and fissures opened by explosion. The evidence in favour of the latter alternative may be illustrated under two heads: E.B.B .
a) If one supposes the breccia, wherever found, to be a superficial deposit, one should be able to reconstruct from its many isolated outcrops a fair picture of the pre-breccia land-surface. However, if one attempt any such reconstruction, it is only to find progress blocked by what appear to be insuperable obstacles. Thus, the hypothetical pre-breccia river-system south-east of Ben More would have to correspond altogether too closely with the modern river system to be at all probable when considered in relation to the number of post-breccia, intrusions developed in the district. The reader will appreciate the force of this argument when he learns that several patches of breccia, too small to be indicated on the one-inch Map, intervene between the two outcrops shown at 1½ and 2 miles, respectively, east-south-east of the summit of Ben More. Of these two, the more easterly is exposed on the floor of Sleibhte-coire, and the more westerly lies 600 ft. higher up and just beyond the summit of a ridge. Exactly the same difficulty presents itself in other localities. For instance on the two slopes of Glen More, facing one another in Cruach Choireadail and Creag na h-Iolaire, patches of breccia are constantly found in association with older rocks. One cannot resist the feeling that these patches are not restricted to a surface, but extend through and through the framework of the country. (C.T.C), E.M.A .
b) A recurrence of breccia-conditions can sometimes be demonstrated under circumstances which seem to render an erosion-origin for the deposit quite impossible. The most striking instance is afforded in the Ben Buie district (
A complete account, or even enumeration, of Mull explosion-vents is not attempted in this chapter. Certain examples have already been dealt with in connexion with the alkali-rocks considered in Chapter 14. Many more must be passed over in silence, except in so far as they are covered by general statements in the sequel. The subject-matter will be divided under four main headings which give prominence to various aspects of the matter:
1. The Materials characteristic of Mull explosion-vents are discussed from the point of view of field-observation. Special attention is directed to the frequent occurrence of rhyolite or rhyolitic debris, and also to the local distribution of gneissic fragments (
2. Under the heading of Repeated Explosions, the whole question of age-relations is dealt with.
3. The Sgùrr Dearg Vents, reaching from Beinn Chreagach Bheag through Sgùrr Dearg, Glas Bheinn, and Ben Buie, to Sleibhte-coire, are given detailed consideration, not only on account of their great intrinsic interest, but also because they may be regarded as good representatives of the explosion-vents of Central Mull taken as a whole.
4. The Petrology of the vent-agglomerates is treated on the same lines as that of the surface-agglomerates of Chapter 15. Descriptions are almost confined to acid rocks associated with the agglomerates, either in solid or fragmental form. In regard to the non-fragmental rhyolites it may be said that they are lettered R on the one-inch Map, just the same as their fellows occurring among the surface agglomerates. The petrological description is closed with an account of contact-alteration induced by subsequent intrusions.
In describing the surface-accumulations of agglomerate (Chapter 15), it has been pointed out that, within the caldera area, some small proportion of the agglomerate coloured on the one-inch Map as vent-agglomerate really rests upon basalt-lavas. The geological complication of the district where this occurs is in fact too great to permit of satisfactory differentation of surface- and vent-agglomerate in every instance, but the uncertainties thus introduced are of very secondary importance.
Materials as observed in the field
The contents of the vent-agglomerates vary from place to place. Tertiary basalt-lavas, Tertiary plutonic rocks, Mesozoic sediments, and Moine gneisses are locally abundant. As in the case of the surface-agglomerate (Chapter 15), rhyolites occur both in mass and as fragments; in fact it is thought that most of the agglomerates of Mull have resulted from the breaking up of country-rock by explosions emanating from acid magma. Rhyolite is particularly abundant in the north-western caldera on both sides of Loch Bà where large outcrops are shown on the one-inch Map. W.B .W., E.B.B.
A feature of very general interest is the virtual limitation of gneiss-fragments to the more peripheral vents. This point is illustrated in
For more than four miles north-westward from Sgùrr Dearg, where vents figure fairly prominently in the lava-country lying outside the calderas, gneiss is still a conspicuous component of the agglomerate, though for the most part represented by small fragments. Of quite exceptional size is a huge block shown on the one-inch Map just south-west of a fault on the north face of Beinn Mheadhon. This mass of gneiss has a triangular outcrop 200 yds. long. It occurs associated with ordinary neck-agglomerate, which seems at this point to be piercing lavas 1500 ft. or so above the base of the volcanic pile. E.B.B.
In the other direction, agglomerate with recognizable gneiss-fragments is a feature of the southern slopes of Ben Buie and of several small vents encountered east of Ben More. In some of these exposures, one must admit that the gneiss has been carried upwards for more than 3000 ft. E.M.A., G.W.L.
Within the Central Calderas, agglomerate or breccia is very freely developed; but it is to all intents and purposes free from gneiss-fragments. W.B.W., E.B.B, J.E.R.
On the reasonable assumption that many of the explosions of the more central and more peripheral regions originated at about the same time and at about the same depth, the contrast illustrated in
Although it does not affect the matter discussed above, it is proper, perhaps, to direct attention here to a little string of gneiss-bearing breccia seen traversing the basalt-lavas near the mouth of Loch Spelve at a point indicated by a note on the one-inch Map. The peculiarity of this occurrence is that the schist-floor at this point consists almost certainly of relatively lowly metamorphosed sediments unrepresented in the breccia-vein. Accordingly it seems probable that the vein was filled from above with material supplied by some explosion which occurred in the gneiss-floored district lying farther west. E.B.B.
Repeated explosions
Before passing on to the consideration of local detail, let us return for a moment to the vitally important matter of the recurrence of explosive activity at widely different periods in the history of Central Mull.
The earliest<ref>If the widespread basal mudstone is a weathered ash, as is probable (p. 54), it betokens considerable explosive activity at the very beginning of the volcanic history of the district.</ref> certain epoch of paroxysmal explosion is responsible, among other things, for the breccias that occupy, not only the Coire Mot. Syncline, but also the long row of gneiss-characterized vents lying more or less outside the caldera limits from Beinn Chreagach Bheag through Sgùrr Dearg and the southern face of Ben Buie to Sleibhte-coire (cf. one-inch Map and
The next great explosive epoch to be distinguished has already been singled out for special notice in the introductory remarks of this chapter. It is responsible for the agglomerate-vent, which has burst its way along the northern margin of the Ben Buie Gabbro west of Loch Airdeglais (
Perhaps to this second period should be attributed a strip of breccia, about a third of a mile west of Cruachan Dearg, and too small to show on the one-inch Map. The agglomerate is clearly later than the Corra-bheinn Gabbro, with which it is seen in contact. It is largely made up of gabbro-fragments, together with little pieces of an acid igneous rock. C.T.C.
The more central agglomerates or breccias are, in certain clear cases, later than neighbouring intrusions; but, at the same time, they are almost altogether earlier than the ring-dykes and other masses shown in
It has just been stated that almost all the agglomerate of Central Mull is earlier than the ring-dykes of
A few small agglomerate-vents have been found in significant association with some of the relatively narrow North-West Dykes of Mull. These occurrences are extremely important as evidence that at any rate a few of the North-West Dykes communicated with the surface. Their consideration is deferred till Chapter 34. E.B.B., G.V.W.
The Sgùrr Dearg vents—detailed account
Under the heading, Repeated Explosions, it has been pointed out that a series of early vents can be traced from Beinn Chreagach Bheag through Sgùrr Dearg and Glas Bheinn to the south slopes of Ben Buie and northwards to Sleibhte-coire. In most respects, apart from the matter of age already discussed, this series is thoroughly typical of the Mull vents in general—of which indeed they constitute a very large part.
Beinn Chreagach Bheag to Beinn Mheadhon
On the basaltic slopes above Fishnish Bay, there are numerous irregular outcrops of breccia, and tuff, consisting largely of broken up basalt with a fair proportion of gneiss, rhyolite, and other foreign ingredients. Except for the immense block of gneiss, already described (p. 202) as occurring near the fault on Beinn nam Meann, the fragments throughout are of moderate to small size, In fact, in the biggest vent, as exposed in Allt Mòr Coire nan Eunachair, tuff frequently grades into well-bedded volcanic grit and mudstone.
In addition to rhyolite-ash, there are many outcrops of unbroken small-felspar rhyolite of the same type as occurs associated with the agglomerates of the Coire Mòr. Syncline (Chapter 15). Some of the more important of these outcrops are inserted on the one-inch Map.
The transgressive relationship of the ashes of this district is shown by their not mapping out as regularly interstratified beds would do. The only outcrop, which seems at first sight to be that of an intercalated ash, contours the hill-side for about half a mile, as indicated on the Map, two-thirds of a mile south of Bailemeonach Cottage. South of this outcrop, there rises a low lava-scarp as if belonging to a later overlying flow. However, the appearance can be shown to be misleading, for near the eastern extremity of the exposure the breccia is seen to cut up across the lava-scarp in a most striking fashion. It is interesting to note that the breccia here is richly charged with gneiss and granophyre, thus suggesting an underground extension of the Glas Bheinn Granophyre suite of intrusions (Chapter 12).
One of the most striking features connected with these vents, taken as a whole, is the way the neighbouring basalt-lavas go to pieces in their vicinity. This is capitally seen round about the largest vent. The shattered basalt is veined with epidote, and it is significant that both shattering and veining antedate the Beinn Mheadon Felsite (Chapter 17), and also the Early Acid and Early Basic Cone-Sheets of the district (Chapters. 19 and 21). It may be added that, at their numerous contacts with the agglomerate-filled vents, all these intrusions clearly cut through the agglomerate.
Sgùrr Dearg
The agglomerate of Sgùrr Dearg consists for the most part of a coarse unbedded breccia made of blocks of gneiss, granophyre, and basalt, with subordinate big-felspar gabbro, Triassic sandstone, rhyolite, etc. At two points marked H and K in
In considering
The brecciation of the gneiss and early intrusions everywhere within
Evidence that the vent-agglomerate is later than the Sgùrr Dearg Big-Felspar Gabbro of Chapter 11 is afforded by contacts lettered A and I on
Evidence that the vent-agglomerate is later than the Glas Bheinn Granophyre of Chapter 12 is supplied by the contacts lettered F, G, and H
Evidence that the vent-agglomerate is later than the Torness Felsite of Chapter 17 is afforded in stream sections to which the reader is referred in the explanation of the letter E,
The vent-agglomerate is earlier than the Beinn Mheadhon Felsite of Chapter 17, but the latter is itself so much cut up by later intrusions within
Glas Bheinn and Loch Spelve
There is such a mass of Early Basic Cone-Sheets in the Glas Bheinn country that little can be deciphered of the original held-relations of the continuation of the Sgùrr Dearg agglomerate-outcrop south-westwards past Was Bheinn summit. In the more open country near Loch Spelve, there are a few easily accessible breccia-exposures to which attention may usefully be directed. In four of these, the agglomerate, or breccia, is seen in contact with, and in large measure derived from, intrusions of the Glas Bheinn Granophyre suite of Chapter 12:
(1) A small vent exposed in Abhuinn Coire na Fèola, two-thirds of a mile above road; it is shown on the one-inch Map just north-east of a north-west basalt-dyke.
(2 and 3) The southern margin of a vent exposed in two streams separated by Teanga Bhàn, respectively 200 yards north-west and 500 yards north-east of Kinlochspelve Farm.
(4) A minute, but rather conspicious, vent towards the head. of Allt a' Ghoirstein Uaine, 1300 yards up from Creach Bheinn Lodge. The vent is not shown on the one-inch Map, but is easily located on the north-west bank of the stream, 100 yards up Irons the mouth of a little tributary that enters Allt a' Ghoirtein Uaine from the north.
The material of these Loch Spelve vents sometimes grades to line sediments. Much of the deposit seen in the streams north-west of Loch Spelve is a bedded sandstone derived from the attrition of granophyre. The bedding is now generally at high angles. E.B.B.
Ben Buie
Attention has already been directed to the vents opened successively on the south and north sides of Ben Buie (p. 199). The more southerly vent is an obvious continuation of the Sgùrr Dearg and Glas Bheinn series. Its material consists largely of granophyre-debris with many fragments of gneiss, and is cut across by Early Acid and Early Basic Cone-sheets (Chapters 19 and 21) followed by Ben Buie Gabbro (Chapter 22). G.V.W.
Sleibhte-coire
There are comparatively few peripheral vents north-west from Ben Buie, and most of them are of small size. The largest example is rather less than half a mile long, and is exposed in Sleibhte-coire between Tòrr na h-Uamha and Guibean Uluvailt. It is thoroughly typical of its kind, and its agglomerate, containing fragments of gneiss, is cut across by Early Basic Cone-Sheets (Chapter 21 and Corra-bheinn Gabbro (Chapter 22). (C.T.C)
Petrology
The most striking feature of the assemblage of rocks dealt with in the present chapter is the preponderance of what may be termed the foreign or accidental element in the constitution of the agglomerates. Naturally only the finer parts of the volcanic breccias can be examined microscopically, and on the whole there is little additional information to be gathered from the many slides that have been prepared to illustrate the phenomena recounted in the Field Descriptions. Moine gneisses and Tertiary granophyres, gabbros, and lavas are all abundantly represented as blunted rock-fragments, degenerating by further comminution into angular crystal-debris. Olivine is always decomposed, but felspar and augite, even where separately enclosed in the breccia-matrix, are sometimes unaltered.
Instead of elaborating this side of the subject, our attention will be directed more particularly to the acid rocks which, whether in mass or fragments, may be regarded as the probable representatives of the magma responsible for the explosions that produced the breccias and agglomerates.
Associated rhyolites
The main development of rhyolite in association with vent-agglomerate was investigated by Mr. Wright, and occurs in the north-western caldera indicated in
A specimen collected west of Loch Bà, from the stream that flows out of the lochan one mile west-north-west of Clachaig Cottage, proves to be a partially devitrified obsidian (S17126)
Other specimens were collected on the east side of Loch Bà, and are located as follows: (S14847)
In the south-eastern caldera, rhyolite has again been found associated with vent-agglomerate, at Beinn Chàisgidle, though not on a sufficiently large scale to show on the map. The rock (S17931)
Outside the two calderas, minor outcrops of acid rock have been encountered at several localities in connexion with vent-agglomerate, notably in the neighbourhood of Beinn Chreagach Mhòr. A specimen (S16444)
Similar occurrences are met with in association with the vent agglomerates on the south-west of the calderas, though they are too small to show on the one-inch Map. A specimen taken from the Sleibhte-coire Vent, midway between Tòrr na h'Uamha and Guibean Uluvailt, is again of the small-felspar type (S16279)
Acid fragments
An examination of a large suite of slides shows that fragments of acid rocks of glassy or very finely crystalline texture are to be met with everywhere among the vent-agglomerates. Occasionally, they are the main constituent of a coarse volcanic grit (S16476)
More than one type is commonly met with in a single slice, so that, in general, specific localities are omitted from the following brief summary. The types represented include: perlitic non-porphyritic rhyolites (S14679)
Contact-alteration
Several specimens in the collection illustrate the local baking of the agglomerates by later intrusions. A rock (S14685)
Another rock (S16445)
The vent-agglomerate of Sleibhte-coire situated between Tòrr na h' Uamha and Guibean Uluvailt is locally invaded by granophyre (S16280)