Harker, A. 1904. The Tertiary igneous rocks of Skye. HMSO for the Geological Survey.
Chapter 24 augite-andesite and pitchstone dykes
We proceed to give a brief account of some of the andesite dykes of Skye. Rocks with the characters of typical augite-andesites form dykes, usually of small size,<ref>The only large dyke observed which probably belongs here is one 30 feet wide running in contact with a coarse 70-ft diabase dyke in the Harrabol crofts. The rock is rather fine-textured and has the specific gravity 2/5, but has not been examined microscopically.</ref> in the neighbourhood of Broadford and in numerous parts of the Sleat district. These localities fall within the range of the Broadford and Sleat group of dykes described above, and these, as we have seen, are in great part intermediate between trachytes and andesites, while some are frankly andesitic. It is possible that the rocks now to be noticed are likewise related genetically to the trachytes and trachy-andesites; but, showing no trachytic affinities in their petrographical characters, they will be severed from the preceding group as probably distinct, and we shall show that they stand in close relation to another group of rocks to be described, viz. the acid pitchstones.
Our augite-andesite dykes show some variety of characters, and, though we have no chemical data, it is evident from the microscopical examination and from specific gravity determinations that they differ among themselves in chemical composition. These differences are in great measure connected with the existence in some varieties of a considerable amount of glassy base, the rocks in which glassy matter is abundant being more acid than those which contain little or none. The point has been emphasised by Professor Judd<ref>Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc., vol. xlvi., pp. 371–382, pl. XV.; 1890.</ref> in his account of the "younger augite-andesites" of the Western Isles, among which doubtless our rocks are to be included.
As an example of the most crystalline type we take a specimen from a dyke ⅔ mile W.S.W. of Sgòrach Breac, or about 1½ mile E. of Ord, in Sleat, It is a dark grey close-grained rock, with only a few small phenocrysts and some small round spots which look like amygdules. Its specific gravity 2.80 shows that, for an andesite, it is of relatively basic composition. In a slice (S6858)
We have here an instance of a phenomenon which seems to be not uncommon in this group of rocks throughout Britain. Vesicles in the rock have been filled, or partly filled, at a late stage in the consolidation, by an oozing in of the residual fluid magma. This is doubtless of more acid composition than the bulk of the rock. It has usually consolidated mainly or wholly as a glass, which, however, may have been subsequently devitrified. Mr Teall<ref> Geol. Mag., 1889, pp. 481–483, p1. XIV.</ref> has remarked the peculiarity in the andesitic dyke of Tynemouth. Professor Judd<ref>Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc., vol. xlvi., p. 378; 1890.</ref> has recorded it in a rock of specific gravity 2.89, apparently a basic andesite, occurring on Ben Hiant, Ardnamurchan, and regarded by that author as a lava-flow but by Sir A. Geikie as an intrusive sill. Professor Sollas<ref>Sci. Proc. Roy. Dubl. Soc. (2), vol. viii., p. 93; 1893.</ref>. has noticed the same thing in an augite-andesite dyke at Barnesmore in Donegal.
Those andesites which contain a moderate amount of glassy base exhibit usually the "hyalopilitic" structure of Rosenbusch, and have often a fine texture. A good example is from a dyke at Glas Eilean, Bromlford (S9442)
A different type, much richer in glass, is represented by a dyke on the shore of Loch Eishort, W. of Boreraig (S3201)
Another type corresponds with the "tholeiite" of Rosenbusch, with characteristic "intersertal" structure. Here the proportion of glassy base may vary between wide limits, even in different parts of one dyke. A good example is a dyke between Rudha Guail and Loch na Dal, on the coast N.E. of Isle Ornsay. This becomes richer in glass towards the margin, and has a thin tachylytic selvage. One slice of this dyke (S5423)
The extreme glassy type of andesite is illustrated by a dull grey rock of specific gravity 2.15 from a dyke in Broadford Bay (S9441)
Rocks in any way comparable with the above seem to be at least very rare in Skye outside the area which has been indicated; but certain rocks from Druim an Eidhne may be mentioned here as probably devitrified andesitic pitchstones. The best example was found as a dyke, a foot in width, intersecting the gabbro on the highest point of the ridge named. It is a grey, compact, and rather splintery rock of specific gravity 2.79, with a strongly-marked fine banding, caused by lines and little spots of dark greenish-grey upon a lighter ground. The little spots, as seen on the hand-specimen, suggest spherulites. In a thin slice (S8702)
A point to which we have already alluded is the relation subsisting between the augite-andesites and pitchstones in the same area. Not only do the andesitic dykes contain in many cases a variable amount of glassy base, and come to be represented in some instances by practically vitreous rocks, still of intermediate acidity; but there seems to be a somewhat intimate relationship between the andesites and true pitchstones of acid composition. This is better illustrated in some other parts of the British province — e.g. in Arran — than in Skye, but a few words on the subject will not be out of place.
Professor Judd,<ref>Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc., vol. xlvi., p. 379; 1890.</ref> in a paper already cited, has remarked on the tendency in these "younger augite-andesites" for the glassy to become separated from the crystalline portion. The point is an interesting one as perhaps throwing light upon one kind of differentiation — viz., that effected by the separation, or partial separation, of the crystals already formed at a given stage from the residual fluid magma.<ref>Compare also Judd in Geol, Mag., 1888, pp. 1–11.</ref> The composition of the residual magma thus separated would depend upon the stage of consolidation at which the process was effected: it might be sub-acid or thoroughly acid. Again we may recognise different degrees of separation, depending upon circumstances, as follows: (i.) a patchy arrangement on a small scale of the glassy base in the augite-andesites, such as is often seen in slices, and the oozing of the magml, into vesicles as noted above; (ii.) kernels and patches of larger size, composed of relatively acid glass, embedded in an andesitic dyke; (iii.) composite dykes of augite-andesite and pitchstone, such as those of Cir Mhòr and Tormore in Arran<ref>Judd, Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc., vol. xlix., 536–564; 1893.</ref>; and (iv.) separate dykes of augite-andesite and pitchstone associated in the same area.
The second of these four cases is illustrated by one example from Skye cited by Professor Judd. It is from Bealach a' Mhaìm and presumably from a dyke; though the mode of occurrence is not recorded. The dyke-rock itself is stated to have a specific gravity 2.89, and must therefore be of considerably basic composition. The glass which occurs locally as patches in the midst of it yielded the analysis here quoted in column I.: its relatively acid nature, and especially its high content of alkalies, are very remarkable. For comparison we have the Eskdale dyke, in Dumfriesshire, described by Sir A. Geikie, with enclosed glassy portions of which analyses are quoted under B and C. It is interesting to refer also to the Armathwaite dyke, described by Mr Teall, an augite-andesite closely like some of those of the Western Isles and doubtless belonging to the same group. It illustrates how the interstitial base of such a rock, which yields 58 per cent. of silica in bulk-analysis, may be comparable in composition with some acid pitch-stones (see column C)
I | A | B | C | |
SiO2 | 61.80 | 58.67 | 65.49 | 70.76 |
Al2O3 | 14.91 | 14.37 | 14.66 | 10.93 |
Fe2O3 | 8.27 | 1.64 | 3.59 | |
FeO | not det. | 6.94 | 5.44 | not det. |
MnO | not det. | trace | ||
MgO | 0.27 | 4.65 | P57 | 4.21 |
CaO | 3.33 | 7.39 | 3.73 | 3.29 |
Na2O | 6.50 | 3.01 | not det.} | 7.22 |
K2O | 5.19 | 1.42 | not det.} | by diff. |
Ignition | 0.87 | 2.02 | not det. | |
101.14 | 100.11 | 100.00 | ||
Specific gravity | 2.63 | 2.7 |
I. Glass in "labradorite-andesite" (? dyke), Bealach a Mhaìm, between Sligachan and Glen Brittle: mean of duplicate analyses by S. Parrish and H. J. Taylor, Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc., vol. xlvi., p. 364; 1890.
A. Glassy portion of the Eskdale dyke, near Eskdalemuir Manse, Dumfriesshire: anal. J. G. Grant-Wilson, Proc. Roy. Phys. Soc. Ellin., vol. v., p. 253; 1880.
B. Isolated kernels of black glass dispersed through the same rock: anal. J. G. Grant-Wilson, ibid., p. 254.
C. Insoluble residue of Armathwaite dyke, Cumberland, amounting to 35.57 per cent. of the rock, and representing approximately the insterstitial base: anal. W. F. K. Stock, Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc., vol. xl., p. 225; 1884.
We have next to describe the acid pitchstones of our area. Pitchstone is a rock of comparatively rare occurrence in Skye; but in virtue of its very distinctive appearance it attracts the eye wherever it is found", and it was recorded by some of the earliest explorers of the island. As the observed occurrences are few, and exemplify more than one variety of the rock, we shall notice them severally. They are all situated nearly on one line running N.W.–S.E.; and with one exception they are within or closely on the border of the granite area (see
Two or three pitchstone dykes occur on Glamaig. Jameson<ref>Mineralogy of the Scottish Isles, vol. ii., p. 90; 1800. </ref> found here fragments of yellowish and green pitchstone, but was -not able to discover their source. Macculloch<ref>Descr. West. Isl, Scot., vol. i., p. 401; 1819.</ref> noted fragments of two varieties, one black with a few glassy felspars enclosed, the other olive-green with a structure (spherulitic) which he remarked as a novel peculiarity. Von Oeynhausen and von Dechen<ref>Karsten's Archiv für Mineralogie, vol. i., p. 85, pl. III., fig. 2; 1829.</ref> found a dyke 2 or 3 feet wide of dark green spherulitic pitchstone, apparently on the north face of the eastern peak of Glamaig, at ¾ of the height of the hill, besides loose fragments of the black variety. Zirkel<ref>Zeits. deuts. geol. Ges., vol xxiii., p. 89; 1871.</ref> uses nearly the same language as the authors just quoted, but it is not clear whether he refers to the same dyke.
At least two pitchstone dykes intersect the granite of Glamaig, and these are the most northerly and the most westerly of which we have found any evidence in Skye. One at about 1300 feet altitude, or about half-way up, on the western slope is not that of von Oeynhausen and von Dechen, but may possibly be the same that was recorded by Zirkel. It bears N.W. by N., and has a width of about 2 feet, but seems to be a double dyke, consisting of two members each about a foot wide. The purely glassy portion is of a dark greenish grey colour, and has a specific gravity 2.31. It encloses only rare crystals of felspar up to ⅛ inch in length, but more frequently little spherulites. These are usually only 1/10 inch to 1/20 in diameter, but some, especially in the dull devitrified portion of the dyke, reach a diameter of an inch. The glass is pale yellow in a thin slice (S8733)
There is more than one dyke of this type on Glamaig, for fragments of a rock closely resembling that just described occur in the screes some 600 feet higher up. Macculloch's black porphyritic pitchstone belongs probably to still another dyke concealed by the screes. We have not found it on Glamaig itself, but boulders of it occur in the drift of the district on the line of the other Glamaig boulders. It is a black rock with pitchy lustre, enclosing fresh felspars up to 4 inch in length, and having, like most of these pitchstones, a certain fissile character. A specimen from the drift near Drynoch Lodge gave the specific gravity 2.37. A specimen of the well known rock of the Sgùrr of Eigg, selected for its resemblance to these boulders, gave 2.42. The resemblance, however, seems to be a superficial one only. The felspars in our rock are wholly of a monoclinic species, with carlsbad twins. The other porphyritic elements are green augite crystals and some small octahedra of magnetite. The ground-mass has a yellowish colour, with evident flow-structure. It encloses little rods, from 0.005 inch downward, of faint green colour and presumably of hornblende or augite; the smaller ones are gathered into stellate groupings, each surrounded by a clear space. Much more minute crystallitic growths disseminated through the colourless glassy base impart the yellowish tint and slight turbidity which are noticeable with a low magnification,
The next locality for pitchstone is on the eastern slope of Glas Bheinn Mhòr. Loose fragments are found beside the Strath Mòr foot-path, in some of the scree-deltas thrown out by the small streams which intersect the slope. Our attention was called to these fragments by Sir A. Geikie; but, though their source is probably in the immediate neighbourhood, we have not succeeded in detecting it, and it is probably concealed under the screes. The rock has a dark olive-brown glassy ground-mass enclosing closely-set crystals of felspar up to ¼ inch long. Its specific gravity is 2.44, Thin slices show that, besides felspars, both oligoclase and sanidine, green augite and magnetite figure among the phenocrysts, and these several minerals are grouped in aggregates. Some felspar crystals are so honeycombed with inclusions of the groundmass that they consist to the extent of fully one-half of glass. A more unusual feature is the occurrence of quartz micrographically intergrown in felspar phenocrysts and of radiating fringes of micro-pegmatite bordering groups of crystals. The glassy ground-mass has a yellowish cloudy appearance, due to an immense number of very minute crystallitic elements visible only with a high magnifying power. They are partly globulites, partly short rods. Perlitic fissures are sometimes seen surrounding the phenocrysts
It is probable that more than one dyke of pitchstone occurs on this slope of Glas Bheinn Mhòr, for, at a spot not far north of the last, two pitchstone boulders were found in the drift of Strath Mòr, which differ from the variety just noted. One contains only scattered rectangular felspars about ⅛ inch long in a grey ground-mass. This has a patchy appearance from the intermingling of truly vitreous portions with others of somewhat duller, enamel-like aspect. The specific gravity of this rock is 2.34. A thin slice shows that besides the felspar phenocrysts there are, as usual, smaller ones of augite and a few grains of magnetite. The felspar is sanidine, and it encloses large patches of glass, besides crystals of augite and magnetite. The yellow and rather cloudy glass which forms the matrix owes its appearance to a crowd of minute globulites, barely resolved under a high-power objective. The other boulder from this place has a specific gravity 2.346. Under the microscope it shows a similar yellow glass, in which sanidine phenocrysts are embedded, and the yellowish turbidity is resolved with high magnification into a vast number of very minute rods and globulites. There are little clear spaces surrounding green microlites of larger dimensions, though still less than 1/500 inch long, which tend to aggregate into roughly stellate groups, recalling some of the well known pitchstones of Arran.
Jameson<ref>Mineralogy of the Scottish Isles, p. 93; 1800.</ref> in 1800 recorded fragments of dark leek-green pitchstone on the slopes of Beinn na Caillich, and in 1818 discovered their source in the form of a "vein in a stream descending from that mountain", probably Allt a’ Choire, above the farm of Coire-chatachan (see Macculloch,<ref>Descr. West. Isl. Scot., vol. i., p. 401.</ref> passim). Several pitchstone dykes, or dykes composed partly of pitchstone, intersect the granite of Beinn na Caillich. One high up on the northern face does not seem to be exposed, but fragments were found at an altitude of over 2000 feet. It is a deep olive-green glassy-looking rock, enclosing numerous little felspars and other crystals, and the specific gravity was found to be 2.35. A slice (S6796)
Low down on the eastern slopes of the hill two or three dykes occur in the burn Allt a’ Choire, which flows down to Coire-chatachan. A small water-fall at about 350 feet altitude is caused by a triple dyke running nearly E.–W. The two flanking members consist of compact quartz-bearing felsitic rocks which gave specific gravities 2.53 and 2.58 (S8842)
That rocks similar to the pitchstones of the Red Hills occur also in the Sleat district appears from a specimen collected by Mr Clough from a dyke at Allt Duisdale, near Isle Ornsay. It is a dark rock with a pitchy lustre, enclosing scattered felspars up to ⅛ inch long, and having the specific gravity 2.36. It has a marked flow-structure, and also a rough platy or columnar fracture oblique to this. A thin slice (S6130)
The above pitchstones seem by their low specific gravities to be, at least in the main, of acid composition. This criterion is however not entirely satisfactory, and we have already remarked on the resemblance of one of the rocks to that of the Sgùrr of Eigg, which is of sub-acid composition. Published analyses of British Tertiary pitchstones show that those of truly acid nature have specific gravities ranging from 2.29 to 2.37, while the pitchstone of Barnesmore Gap in Donegal (with 64.04 per cent. of silica) gives 2.41, and that of the Sgùrr of Eigg (with 65.81 per cent.) 2.42. These sub-acid glasses are therefore very little denser than others containing 8 or 10 per cent. more silica.
Although pitchstones are of comparatively rare occurrence in Skye, there are in places very numerous dykes which, although not glassy, reproduce in other respects the characteristics of that group of rocks, and are perhaps to be regarded as devitrified and otherwise altered pitchstones. — They are dykes of no great width, usually only a foot or two, exceptionally as much as six or even ten feet. Their direction is commonly about W.N.W.–E.S.E., but varies in extreme cases from W.–E. to N.S. They are dull compact-looking rocks, often crowded at the margin with little spherules which show conspicuously on a weathered face; and these are sometimes alligned so as to give what Mr Clough has styled a "rodded" structure. A number of specimens were examined from the neighbourhood of Coire-chatachan and the slopes of Beinn na Caillich. Five of these gave specific gravities ranging from 2.45 to 2.54, with a mean of 2.50. For the sake of clearness we will refer to these presumably altered rocks as the Coire-chatachan type. Their local distribution is indicated in
Before describing these dykes it should be observed that rocks of precisely similar characters are found in immediate association with typical pitchstones, and there have every appearance of an identical origin. Thus the dark green pitchstone of Glamaig, already described, passes into a dull grey compact rock, with fluxion-lines weathering out as slender ribs on an exposed face. A thin slice (S8841)
Some of the Coire-chatachan dykes, though now devoid of vitreous matter, show so close a general resemblance to the rock just described that we may confidently assign to them a like origin. Good examples are afforded by a dyke (sp. gr. 2.54) about 1100 yards N.N.E. of the old house of Coire-chatachan and another (sp. gr. 2.53) in the lower part of Allt a’ Choire. Slices (S6785)
Other examples show what must be regarded as a more radical kind of alteration, probably affecting the bulk composition of the rock; and in such cases the term ‘"devitrification" does not adequately express the changes undergone. A 10 ft dyke about 900 yards N. of the old house is of a dull compact rock with strong flow-structure, marked by closely alternating whitish and greenish grey bands: the specific gravity is 2.52. A slice (S6784)
A dyke seen on the coast to the N.N.E. of Corry Lodge, Broadford, has characters which in many respects resemble those of the more altered of the Coire-chatachan dykes, and is possibly like them a transformed glassy rock; but it is essentially different from them in its original nature. It contains abundant crystals of quartz, and must have been a rock of thoroughly acid composition.